I remember vividly that on September 25, 2003 – five years ago – I flew from, Jakarta to Singapore for one single purpose: see the band that I had been a fan for nearly 30 years to play live “Yes – Second Leg Tour“. And that was the first time I was in Yes concert and it was a great experience that I would never forget the rest of my life. Last night, I did not need to fly to Singapore to gain the same experience because it required me to do just an inbound transport to reach the new Salihara Concert Hall at Pejaten, South Jakarta, Indonesia to see the best Indonesian true progressive band, Discus, plays live. I planned to see the concert weeks ago from Fadhil (keyboard) and Krisna (keyboard) Face Books. Unfortunately at the day of the concert, I was swamped the whole day until late afternoon in my Client’s office discussing strategic issues of my current consulting engagement. The meeting was so important and time consuming as so many thoughts provoking discussions going on. As the time approaching to 8 PM I was so afraid that I would miss the show. But I kept telling myself that “I choose to go, no matter what!”. Well, life is about priority and in my view proggin’ is more important than consulting. Don’t you agree with me? So, I decided to go for the show and postponed the consulting work for tomorrow because I do really want to see Discus! Proggin’ matters to me, really!

I reached the venue – oh man …it’s a great venue, indeed! – at 8:20 PM when Discus already played their music. Jreng! The first impression: awesome! The stage was actually at the same level with the main entrance floor. There was no raised floor that determines the stage boundary. It’s good, I believe, because the performers (bands, dancers, poets, etc.) can set their own stage boundary-less. Well, of course, there was front row seat that limit the stage, but it’s quite huge for a any band or dance company to perform. I saw Anto Praboe (clarinet, sax, flute, trompet penca, growl, etc) at the right-most corner of the stage and Iwan Hasan (guitar, harp, vocal) at his left side. Krisna Prameswara (keyboards) stood behind Iwan and Hayunaji (drums) is at the back center of the stage. At the same position as Iwan but at the left wing was Eko Partitur (violin) and behind him was Fadhil Indra (keyboards, electronic percussion). Kiki Caloh with his bass guitar (was it Rickenbaker?) stood mobile at front stage, sometime in the middle of left wing, closed to Eko Partitur. The female vocal, Yuyun, moved around the stage and she sometimes performed dancing while the music played.
I was impressed with the sound quality and acoustic standard of the hall which to my ears sounded excellent. I stood at the entrance pathway, at the right side of the stage and took pictures from this position. Theoretically, it’s not a strategic position to enjoy the show .. but the sound was excellent. Well, sometimes Iwan Hasan’s sound quality produced more uncontrolled distortion in some musical segments but overall it’s OK for my ears.
As I rolled into the venue, I was not quite sure what the band was playing because recently I have rarely played Discus CDs due to many new prog albums I have been listening to recently so I got lost on track titles even though I knew from which album the music was. But they did not play only those on the albums because some new tracks (previously unreleased) were also played by Discus. For sure, when I entered the concert hall, they played “Breathe” because I am familiar with Anto’s growling vocal. Even though I was just at the end of the track, I found their performance was awesome. They produced balanced sound on nearly every single instrument even though not quite heavy on keyboards department. It’s truly a progressive music live performance as it produced complexity, even though at the expense of catchy melody. The brilliant approach taken by the band is their composition that features excellent interlude from sax, flute, clarinet or sometimes interjected by dazzling violin work, rude guitar distortion and dynamic drumming. So, it’s simply to say that I don’t mind not getting catchy melody – remember, my background is basically more towards symphonic prog with great melody – as long as I can get great combination of solos of multiple instruments. And, Discus has done brilliant job in this matter. I can think of their music is much more sophisticated than the most complex composition Frank Zappa has ever made. I am not exaggerating it being the fact that I am truly a proud Indonesian. (Do you know a prog band called Frogg Café? Discus music, without ethnic insertion, is probably similar to Frogg Café’s).
Multiple Musical Orgasms
After some chit chats by Iwan Hasan – because the concert was conducted in relaxed way – they then played the bonus track of their second album, “…Tot Licht!” called the “Misfortune Lunatic” with heavy tinge on jazz-fusion type of thing. I enjoyed the track, really. Next was my favorite ethnic-based composition from their debut “Lamentation and Fantasia Gamelantronique”. Looking at the title, it’s a self-indulgent bombastic name, I believe you might say. But hey …turn your ears and open your mind, play this tune! I am pretty damn sure you will be amazed with how geniuses the boys in the band have ever composed the music that I believe any western band can make. It’s a fabulous composition and it’s awesome being performed live! Oh man … I found myself having peak musical orgasm when this song was played. I like the great combination of traditional music characterized by the melody delivered by flute with avant-garde style and …jaw dropping drum work by Hayunaji. Oh my God …! He’s a fabulous drummer at par excellent with Bill Bruford, I believe. His strokes are truly wonderful and complex. I said to Lody (my young prog mate who stayed closed to me during the show) that Hayuniaji is really the best progressive (in real term! Not crossover prog or the like!) that Indonesia has ever had. No one can match his dynamic drumming really.
I thought I already reached my peak during Lamentation, but it was not because the next track after they played acoustic (which I do not like, actually) with “Condisonance – Music for 5 Players”, they did another fabulous performance that made me nggeblak! (my mind being stunned and paralyzed) due to the beauty of the composition and brilliant live performance. I think the title was “Jazzdance of The Equatorial Winds” which has never been recorded before. It started with something in percussive nuances through the use of traditional instruments like rindik, being played by almost all musicians. Nuance-wise it reminded me to the interlude part of “I’m A Man” by Chicago Transit Authority. Throughout this song the band demonstrated their fullest potentials as every individual musician contributed their best performance. Throughout the show I had been watching how Kiki Caloh played his bass guitar dynamically and through this song he was given a chance to feature his bass guitar solo, for a while. Fadhil Indra performed great electronic percussion that I though something like a vibraphone. I was amazed when he played solo on this. Krisna Prameswara sometimes played his keyboard like Chick Corea. Anto Praboe also played his solo trumpet penca (well, I don’t know really the name of the instrument but it seemed like it. It’s typically used also with our traditional Reog Ponorogo). Iwan also performed his solo. Eko Partitur maneuvered his violin work brilliantly. And, again .. I was extremely amazed with Hayunaji drumwork – it’s fabulous! Hayunaji rules!
Overall, I was totally satisfied with Discus performance last night and I really hope that they release their third album soon. To summarize the show, it was an excellent combination of brilliant composition, dynamic performance and balanced sound quality. I have seen Discus live many times but last night performance is really their best performance ever! Having experienced this, I am really proud being an Indonesian because Indonesia has these top notch musicians under the banner of Discus. Bravo Discus! ..and keep on proggin’ for all of you who read this damn long review (I can’t help it, I can’t make it shorter ….and I do not need to apologize because this is the world of PROG! It’s truly your mistake why you have engaged your eyes reading this meaningless review … Shame on you man!).
Peace on earth and mercy mild – GW (i-Rock! Music Community)
Discus Live at Festival Salihara
Jakarta, November 5, 2008-11-06
Setlist: (informed by Fadhil Indra)
- Verso Kartini
- Breathe
- Misfortune Lunatic
- Lamentation and Fantasia Gamelantronique
- Condissonance / Music for 5 Players (acoustic)
- Jazzdance of The Equatorial Winds
- Fantasia of 2 Makassar
- Anne
- System Manipulation